Traditional financial services players such as Barclays and c joined leaders from the virtual currency and Blockchain world, to meet with policymakers from across the EU institutions in a series of roundtables organised by the European Digital Currency & Blockchain Technology Forum (EDCAB) in the European Parliament.
Participants were also joined by the World Bank, IMF, the Bank for International Settlements, OECD, the European Securities and Markets Authority and Europol to discuss how to best to develop an optimal regulatory framework for the nascent sector.
EDCAB Founder, Siân Jones, moderated sessions on the economic benefit of virtual currency, trusting distributed ledgers and ensuring effective and proportionate legislation.
The roundtable series comes at an important time. Virtual currencies have rapidly risen up the European policy agenda in all the major institutions. On Tuesday, the European Parliament’s Economic and Monetary Affairs Committee discussed their report on future regulation of the European virtual currency and Blockchain industry. The influential Internal Market and Consumer Protection Committee also met yesterday and today to review and discuss amendments to their opinion on the report.
“As the only independent European public policy platform for virtual currencies and distributed ledger technology, EDCAB is delighted to be playing a leading role in shaping discussions between industry and policymakers in order to secure a sound regulatory and policy landscape”.
The sector has benefited from cross party support and roundtables were well attended with participants from all European institutions.
Syed Kamall MEP, Chair of the European Conservatives and Reformists Group opened discussions on ‘Virtual currencies: The future of money’:
“I believe that it is essential that we don’t just discuss these issues behind closed doors but open these debates up to everyone. If we get it right, Blockchain and virtual currency technologies offer us many opportunities, not just for institutions but also for individuals and we need to make sure they are part of that debate”.
Eva Kaili MEP, Socialists and Democrats member, hosting the discussion on ‘Blockchain: Trusting distributed ledgers’ added:
“The technology is there and the opportunities and challenges must be faced and embraced as a priority. As part of this I have asked for a separate report of the INTA Committee to ensure that the groundbreaking potential of the technology is fully embraced.”
Ashley Fox MEP on ‘Regulating virtual currencies and Blockchain: A balancing act’ remarked:
“We look to work with industry to inform us on this important issue. There is a consensus in the Parliament, that policymakers should be careful not to regulate the technology out of existence”.
The roundtables demonstrated clear appetite from both policymakers and industry to work together to achieve positive outcomes for the sector.
“EDCAB looks forward to continuing to facilitate informed and engaging on all live issues and future policies which will impact this rapidly developing sector. We are monitoring events closely and will continue to build upon established relationships with stakeholders across institutions to ensure the right outcomes for the sector and the citizens it serves”.
Overview of discussions
Industry and policymakers agreed that Blockchain and virtual currencies democratise finance and give the power to transact back to consumers. There was widespread agreement that Blockchain technologies provide a level of transparency and certainty unlike ever before – with unparalleled benefits to users and providers of financial services.
Industry and policymakers agree that regulation should be descriptive rather than prescriptive. Though the technology is a nascent one, it is a rapidly evolving. This necessitates collaboration between industry and policymakers in order to understand what works and what should be avoided. Devising an appropriate regulation for currencies should take into account the wide range of alternative uses.
It was underlined that digital currencies have been identified by many governments as low risk threats and there is little concrete evidence to suggest that digital currencies are commonly used illegally.
Policymakers underlined that the policy challenge is twofold: to foster a supportive environment to allow industry to grow whilst also reducing the risk of illicit activity and perceived risks.
A need to stimulate and facilitate innovation was a common theme. Participants agreed that regulation needs to be proportionate to the risks presented. For example, regulatory criteria should reflect variables such as the number of transactions or systemic significance. It was suggested that, the lower the risk, the lower the regulatory requirement This would allow for emerging industry players to experiment and build customers.
It was suggested that over regulation is problematic given the fundamental philosophy of Blockchain and virtual currencies, which view financial regulations as obstructions and route around them. Excessive regulation runs the risk of encouraging the emergence of fully obscured functions. It was suggested that policymakers may want to focus on low risk stimulation in areas where regulatory thresholds are low. Once this is properly understood, these learnings could be applied to higher risk applications.
The industry operates in and offers services which are already regulated. It was suggested that before introducing new regulation, the efficacy of the current regulatory regime should be tested. Where regulatory gaps are identified, solutions must be sought; but this must be based on proper understanding of where there are regulatory limitations.
There was broad consensus on the need to develop regulation which promotes legitimacy. It was agreed that there is a need for industry, governments and academia to come together to build standards across the European Union (and on an international level) in different settings to provide a level playing field. The need to avoid competitive arbitrage is crucial – support from government working across Member States would be welcomed, as international cooperation is essential. Policymakers are encouraged to look at best practice across Member States. Industry welcomed the UK’s approach of allowing industry to self regulate and develop standards for consumer protection.
There remain misconceptions and a lack of understanding of technologies. It was agreed that there is a need for industry to be proactive in communicating risks and liabilities to consumers. This is an important step in building legitimacy for the sector and industry agreed on the need to be transparent about how they manage risk and work with policymakers to educate and build public confidence.
The need for policymakers, industry and academia to pool resources and work together to identify and minimise illegal use was also identified.
Access to financial and banking services from the broader financial industry incumbents was also highlighted as a barrier to emerging players and growth of the sector.
- OpenLedger’s Apptrade (www.apptrade.io), the platform creating “Kickstarter for Apps on the Blockchain”, has received a $100,000 USD boost from OpenLedger ApS, the world’s first blockchain powered conglomerate. Powered by the digital token APPX, Apptrade creates portfolios, or groups, of apps, where if one of those apps becomes the next Instagram or Angry Birds, then the value of the portfolio rises. Ronny Boesing, CEO of OpenLedger ApS, explained that Apptrade’s initial token offering (ITO) changed its valuation in the middle of its crowd sale as an immediate response to the result of its preliminary offering. Boesing said, “The Apptrade platform is much too important to not succeed, and it was clear that we needed to adjust the valuation to make it more appealing to anyone deciding to participate. In addition, we wanted to show our belief in this project, and felt that there was no better way to show this than putting our money where our mouth is. OpenLedger will be adding a total of $100 000 USD to the Crowdsale over the next 7 days.” The minimum fundraising goal is $1M USD with a cap of $5M USD. With a total of 8.25M APPX tokens on offer, OpenLedger’s Apptrade ApS will back these tokens with 20% of the future revenue from the Apptrade platform, and any unsold tokens will therefore be distributed proportionally to all participants. All early bird participants, as well new participants, will receive the extra tokens according to the published Stage 1 structure, plus benefit from the additional tokens to be divided. Daniel Pineda, Founder of Apptrade says, “After listening carefully to feedback from public and private supporters, and with great consideration, we decided to update our master token valuation. We firmly believe that our platform, built on the ecosystem of OpenLedger and powerful BitShares financial trading technology, is a strong Blockchain project that will be a success for years to come. We feel that this is the right action to ensure a satisfactory outcome for all.” Apptrade’s final valuation is going to be based on the amount raised, whether $1M USD as its threshold or money back guarantee, or the maximum of $5M USD. The valuation of the Apptrade platform will be determined on what is raised. The deadline according to the escrow agreement is set to end on April 30 2017. Boesing continued, “This approach and change of valuation resulted from requests from within the community, and we hope to accommodate many more participants. But one thing is clear to all of the Early Birds – this is your lucky day!” - March 27, 2017
- Factom Launches Revolutionary Blockchain Suite of Mortgage Products - March 24, 2017
- Qtum Shatters ICO Records Raising $15.6 Million - March 24, 2017
- Blockchain Startup Sphre Announces ICO (Crowdsale) for Digital Identity Platform Called Air - March 22, 2017
- Kestrel sign ups to MTI’s blockchain driven solutions to deliver global growth - March 22, 2017
- The G20 Countries Should Investigate Blockchain Technologies to Build an Inclusive, Transparent, and Accountable Digital Economy for All - March 21, 2017
- Particl, a Distributed Marketplace Rethinking Privacy’s Future – Announced Seed Round - March 21, 2017
- ZrCoin To Do Initial Coin Offering (ICO) to Crowdfunds Commodities Option - March 21, 2017
- Canada’s Scotiabank and AlphaPoint Announce Successful Blockchain Trial - March 21, 2017
- Canada’s SecureKey taps IBM to put identity on the Blockchain - March 21, 2017
- Blockchain Startup Humaniq Launches London Office - March 21, 2017
- QRL Recruits Testers for High Security Quantum-Resistant Blockchain - March 20, 2017
- Blockchain of Things, Inc. Releases Paw Advanced REST Client Integration - March 19, 2017
- ConsenSys Named Official Blockchain City Advisor for the City of Dubai - March 16, 2017
- Bloq Launches BloqLabs to Connect Enterprises with Open Source Blockchain Innovations - March 16, 2017
- Multi-Million Dollar Research Institute Launched to Explore Blockchain Use Cases, Opportunities and Challenges - March 16, 2017
- Chamber of Digital Commerce Forms the Blockchain Intellectual Property Council - March 16, 2017
- Orebits & Symbiont Deploy Blockchain Technology to Digitize Gold Ownership - March 16, 2017
- Blockchain Capital to Raise its Third Fund via a Digital Token Offering in The First Liquidity-enhanced Venture Capital Fund - March 16, 2017
- The Exscudo Channels App Is A New Mobile Wallet And Secure Messenger - March 14, 2017
- Dao.Casino – Decentralising the Gambling Economy - March 14, 2017
- Chain of Points Adds American Internet Entrepreneur Jeff Pulver to Board of Advisors - March 14, 2017
- Nasdaq Releases NYIAX – A Blockchain-Enabled, Cloud-Based Media Trading Platform - March 14, 2017
- Lunyr Announces Crowdsale for the First Decentralized World Knowledge Base on Ethereum - March 14, 2017
- Coinsource, World’s largest bitcoin ATM network, Completes Historic Bulk Installation on US West Coast with 35 ATMs - March 14, 2017
- Bitwala Offers Bitcoin to M-Pesa Services in Kenya, Nigeria, Uganda, and Tanzania - March 12, 2017
- US SEC Regulators Reject Bitcoin ETF, Price Plunges, Recovers - March 11, 2017
- Google’s DeepMind plans Blockchain Health Record Tracking for Hospitals - March 10, 2017
- Coalition Forms to Address Digital Asset Taxation Uncertainty - March 10, 2017
- Livecoin, the Fourth Largest Altcoin Exchange Is Now Available in Eight Languages - March 9, 2017
- Australia Releases Blockchain Standards Roadmap - March 6, 2017
- Hyperledger Fabric Graduates with Honours – It’s Live! - March 4, 2017
- TaaS, the First Fully Transparent Closed End Fund Dedicated to Blockchain Assets, Adds International Banking and Marketing Experts as Advisors - March 2, 2017
- Kraken Acquires Cryptowatch and Launches New Trading Platform - March 1, 2017
- Switzerland’s Crypto Valley Association Founded To Build World’s Leading Blockchain and Cryptographic Ecosystem - March 1, 2017
- Massive Launch by Blockchain Industry for New Enterprise Ethereum Alliance - March 1, 2017
- Monax Joins Hyperledger Project, Brings Ethereum Technology - February 28, 2017
- Chain of Points Adds Internet Pioneer and iPayYou Founder Gene Kavner to Board of Advisors - February 27, 2017
- Chamber of Digital Commerce and Structured Finance Industry Group Partner to bring Blockchain to Securitization - February 27, 2017
- Blockchain Startup Bloq Acquires Blockchain Analytics Pioneer Skry - February 27, 2017
- Edgeless.io Launches its ICO to become the first fully transparent Casino, Offering 0% Edge - February 27, 2017
- Storj Labs Raises $3 Million in Seed Funding - February 26, 2017
- Northern Trust And IBM Pioneer Use Of Blockchain Technology To Help Transform Private Equity Administration - February 26, 2017
- 0x – An Open Protocol for Decentralized Exchange on the Ethereum Blockchain - February 26, 2017
- Global Blockchain Project FERMAT Announces Significant Alpha Release for the “Internet of People” - February 26, 2017
- Blockchain Startup Peerplays Raises $4m Before ICO Even Kicks Off - February 26, 2017
- Numerai Launches Cryptocurrency and New Hedge Fund Built By Data Scientist Network - February 26, 2017
- Disrupt the VC Industry? Brock Pierce and Blockchain Capital to Launch Own Cryptocurrency and ICO - February 26, 2017
- SoftBank, Sprint and TBCASoft Partner in Blockchain Technology for Telecom Carriers - February 25, 2017
- Lisk Introduces New Blockchain Technology Update - February 25, 2017